Hanno
mvp_badge
MVP
Tab to show who reviewed/rated your component visible to owner/team
1305
Views
5
Comments
Implemented
Community Forge

As a component author, it would be nice to see who rated/reviewed my component.


Justin James
mvp_badge
MVP

Last thing I want is a component author sending me nasty emails because I gave their component a bad rating.

J.Ja

Hanno
mvp_badge
MVP

Dear Justin.

Thank you for your comment. 

I agree that the scenario you mentioned would not be ideal at all - perhaps you should be able to report such abuse (idea) by a component author and some action could be taken against offenders.

I do however believe that as a component author publishing to a public, open-source forum, one should have the maturity to accept criticism. A negative review is but an opportunity to engage with your audience and address any shortcomings your component could have. Yes, there is the forum discussion, but a reviewer will not necessarily post there.

Having this information available would allow a proactive approach to enhancing the component by allowing you to engage with your audience on a personal level.

Regards
Hanno

Hi Hanno,


just seeing "who rated/reviewed my component" probably wouldn't give you much information on how to improve your component, unless there was some sort of follow up action to contact each user and ask their feedback. 

So I wonder - your goal is to have feedback, in a sentence review format, from your component users, while they review the component?

p.s. - I also the implications mentioned by Justin.

thanks

Changed the status to
Working on it
expected delivery in Q4 2018

Hi Hanno


it will be possible to know who rated/reviewed your components. 

During this and next quarter, we will work hard to grow the forge into a marketplace of high-quality components.

And this makes part of that strategy.

So I have set the status to “Working on it”. We expect it to be ready during Q3/4. I’ll post an update once it’s done!

Cheers 

Ana Sequeira

Changed the status to
Implemented
on 28 Nov 2018

we did it :)